Notes on Chapter 12: The Most Beautiful Theory
Slow uptake by the media – Although the scientific community quickly grasped the revolutionary significance of the 1919 eclipse measurements, the general news media were slower to understand and convey the magnitude of what had been achieved. The delay in recognizing the true importance of Einstein’s breakthrough is described in [Isaacson-1].
Einstein and the Edison test – When a reporter asked Einstein if he knew the speed of sound—a typical question from the so-called “Edison tests” of general knowledge—Einstein gave a characteristically incisive reply: he did not burden his memory with facts that were readily available in textbooks and encyclopedias. This exchange took place during his 1921 visit to Boston [Illy, Ch. 14].
Einstein’s visit to Princeton – Accounts of Einstein’s visit to Princeton and his lectures there can be found in [Isaacson-1, Ch. 13], [Illy, Ch. 13], and [Einstein, 1921]. His brilliance and humor shone through, exemplified by the quip by a student who attended his talks, “I sat in the balcony, but he talked right over my head anyway,” and Einstein’s own memorable remark, “Subtle is the Lord, but malicious he is not.” [Pais].
Chaplin and Einstein at City Lights premiere – One of the most iconic encounters of the era took place at the movie premiere of City Lights, when Einstein and Charlie Chaplin were cheered together by the crowd. Chaplin made his memorable remark to Einstein, “They cheer me because they all understand me, and they cheer you because no one understands you” [Isaacson-1].
Einstein’s views on religion and free will – Einstein did not believe in a personal God but embraced Spinoza’s vision of God as the embodiment of the order and harmony of the universe. He also questioned free will, viewing the universe as fundamentally deterministic. Despite his skepticism of organized religion, he often spoke of a “cosmic religious feeling”—a profound awe at the rationality and beauty of existence [L-Einstein, 1952f], [Isaacson-1, Ch. 17].
Fortunate timing of the eclipse – As explained in [Hoffmann], earlier eclipse expeditions in 1914 intended to test Einstein’s light-deflection predictions were derailed by World War I. This proved very fortunate: calculations based on Einstein’s incomplete “Entwurf” theory at that time would have produced incorrect predictions. By 1919, Einstein had completed general relativity and produced accurate calculations—confirmed by the successful eclipse measurements that catapulted him to fame.
